Personalities Methodology About
Live Verdicts
Cowherd — Celtics dynasty call ▲ CORRECT +42pts S.A. Smith — Bronny top-5 pick ▼ WRONG −28pts Simmons — Wemby ROTY ▲ CORRECT +216pts Portnoy — Chiefs 3-peat ▼ WRONG −540pts Russillo — Lakers miss playoffs ▲ CORRECT +33pts Big Cat — Bears win 12 games ▼ WRONG −41pts Simmons — Celtics cover −220 💙 FD ▲ CORRECT +82pts Portnoy — Knicks +7.5 live 🟠 DK ▼ WRONG −248pts Cowherd — Celtics dynasty call ▲ CORRECT +42pts S.A. Smith — Bronny top-5 pick ▼ WRONG −28pts Simmons — Wemby ROTY ▲ CORRECT +216pts Portnoy — Chiefs 3-peat ▼ WRONG −540pts Russillo — Lakers miss playoffs ▲ CORRECT +33pts Big Cat — Bears win 12 games ▼ WRONG −41pts Simmons — Celtics cover −220 💙 FD ▲ CORRECT +82pts Portnoy — Knicks +7.5 live 🟠 DK ▼ WRONG −248pts
Accountability for sports media

Every call.
On Record.
Forever.

We track every bold prediction from sports media's biggest personalities — scores, draft grades, franchise calls — and score them publicly. No more running from bad takes.

Explore Personalities How scoring works →
NFL NBA MLB NHL
6
Personalities tracked
1,629
Takes on record
69
Open takes
54.8%
Avg accuracy
OTR Leaderboard
View all →
# Personality OTR Score Accuracy In Play Trend SB Score
01
RR
Ryen Russillo
Barstool Sports
847
68.4%
9 takes
▲ +12%
💙 FD
+188
02
BS
Bill Simmons
The Ringer
791
61.2%
7 takes
▼ −3%
💙 FD
+341
03
CC
Colin Cowherd
Fox Sports
734
58.8%
14 takes
▲ +6%
💙 FD
+92
04
MK
Mina Kimes
ESPN
702
63.8%
8 takes
▲ +18%
No deal
—
05
NW
Nick Wright
FS1
661
55.8%
16 takes
▲ +8%
🎸 Hard Rock
+44
06
PM
Pat McAfee
ESPN
628
51.4%
13 takes
▲ +4%
No deal
—
07
SA
Stephen A. Smith
ESPN · First Take
612
49.1%
22 takes
▼ −11%
🟣 PrizePicks
−88
08
BC
Big Cat
Barstool Sports
589
52.3%
11 takes
▼ −8%
🟠 DK
−290
09
SB
Skip Bayless
YouTube / Undisputed
498
41.6%
18 takes
▼ −14%
💙 FD
−214
10
DP
Dave Portnoy
Barstool Sports
544
38.2%
6 takes
▼ −18%
🟠 DK
−380
How OTR Works
Full methodology →
01
We capture every take
Podcasts, radio, TV, columns, social media — every public prediction from tracked personalities is ingested, transcribed, and classified automatically.
02
Every take gets a Line
The OTR Line is calculated from four factors: how bold the call is, how specific the language is, the time horizon, and the category. Bolder, more specific calls carry bigger Lines.
03
Outcomes are verified
When results come in, takes are verified against live sports data. Correct calls bank the full Line. Wrong calls lose it. No partial credit. No running from it.
04
Scores are permanent
The OTR Score is a cumulative running total. It goes up and down as takes resolve. Deleted tweets are archived. Retroactive reframes are flagged. Nothing disappears.